Religious Freedom Does Not Include Discrimination

Religious Freedom Does Not Include Discrimination

Jul 06, 2017
 


By Olivia Case

It was in Colorado Springs on a Monday in June that Charlie Craig and David Mullins were denied their wedding cake. Why? Because they are a same sex couple. 

Owner of Masterpiece Cake Shop Jack Phillips declared it contradictory to his Christian beliefs, arguing that serving them would be a restriction of his religious freedom. The case is going to the Supreme Court, where the newest justice, conservative Neil Gorsuch, will help decide on a case originating in his home state. Court analyst and University of Richmond law professor Carl Tobias acknowledges the implications of the ruling could limit same sex couples in terms of their ability to receive basic services.

Phillips reached out to the lower court last year, commenting that he would not design anything that conflicts with bible’s teaching, including cakes with racist messages. Amongst what he was boycotting was also Halloween, anti-American themes, atheism, and indecency. However, his actions can be understood not as a symbol of his values, but an excuse to discriminate against members of an already marginalized group. 

In the United States, we recognize the separation of church and state, but it’s separation is thinner than its intent and veiled just as thinly. No public business would ever be allowed to reject a couple’s request for a wedding cake based on skin color, even if their religious teachings called for discrimination based on skin color. While any business can have roots in any religion, they cannot deny basic rights and services to others. 

Discrimination towards the LGBTQ community is rooted in religious text, and that interpretation of homosexuality and other walks of life has fueled thousands upon thousands of years of hate, persecution and violence. Denying services based on sexual orientation is simply an extension of that. That’s why Phillips’ refusal of service to Craig and Mullins was rejected by the Colorado Court of Appeals and the state’s Civil Rights Commission. 

This is unfortunately not an isolated incident. Mississippi passed a law that would allow business and government workers to deny services to same gay and lesbian couples. A Washington State florist will be appealing to the high court after being fined under the state’s anti-discrimination law when she would not provide flowers to a same sex wedding. The chief justice of Alabama has ordered probate judges to stop issuing marriage licenses. And of course, we have the infamous Kentucky clerk Kim Davis, who refused to do just that that of her own volition in 2015. She claimed it to be a heaven or hell decision, despite same sex couples in the United States not have a constitutional right to marry. 

This wedding cake incident and related occurrences are a direct result of the current political climate in the United States. Liberal democrats are divided between the mostly older religious, religious people of color, and often younger secular constituents (who are generally the most socially liberal). They’re attempting to separate the party’s progressive values from its Christian roots. Religion’s historical role, specifically Christianity, in liberal politics cannot be ignored

The LGBTQ community has also found support within religion and comfort within the community of faith. This also cannot be ignored.

The civil rights movement was routed in the ideals of the black church, and even the new deal took inspiration from protestant and Catholic teachings. Most recently, democrat Bill Clinton is part of the Baptist church, and Hillary Clinton has roots in the Methodist church. Barack Obama, though secular learned to speak in cadences while attending a black church in Chicago during childhood. Many other democratic leaders have been ministers or attended divinity school. Their backgrounds have allowed them to appeal to religious democratic voters.

Bernie Sanders, who ran for the democratic nomination only to be defeated by Hillary Clinton, is a great example of religion as means of shutting out diversity. Sanders is someone within the minority that faced great difficulty getting past the hurdles of not adhering to Christianity. Even his own political party wanted to use the fact that he was Jewish against him. He struggled with religious black voters in the South, but appealed to young people with his promises towards the LGBTQ community and economic reform. The median age of democrats in the house is over 60, and many are Christian or Christian-leaning, making it hard for the most progressive goals, such as full justice for the same sex couples and the LGBTQ community, to be accomplished. 

The ebbs and flows of the majority create an ecosystem for oppression. We’ve seen this in the institution of Christianity for the majority of its history. Christianity is so well-established, that it’s been the dominate political force in the United States since its founding, which is why it has footing for utilization as a means for oppression in the first place. To use religious freedom as a form of exclusion is no different than using political belief. There is an undercurrent for Christian beliefs to be prioritized in the United States nonetheless. This allows that dominant religion more rights than others, while also providing the legal wiggling room to impact policy as an act of oppression. 

Oppression is exactly what this case represents. 

The expression of religious freedom is being used as a tool for discrimination in this case. Phillips is plainly expressing a religious right to discriminate, and it’s no different than discrimination based on any other factor. The existence of same-sex marriage does not infringe upon the rights of the religious, and their “disagreeable” attitude towards it suggests a level of judgement that reaches disgusted. Using religious freedom to cite a right to denying services is scary. That personal belief that Phillips holds should be separate from the way businesses are owned and operated within the public space. If not, it could open up the floodgates for more similar discrimination. 

This isn’t an issue of liberty. It’s an issue of status. When a business owner declares that they won’t provide services to a costumer based on their type of love, that's exclusion. Don't be mislead into believing that it isn't. 

 


For more information on NCCJ’s variety of social justice educational programs, click here

The opinions and information expressed through News Views posts are solely those of the individual authors and not representative of NCCJ’s overall stance on related issues unless specified. Any information presented as fact could entail inaccuracies or be incomplete. We encourage open discussion through our blog, and welcome respectful responses from everyone.​

Comments

Your blog inspires me every time when I read it. I love reading blogs. I don't excite always by reading blog posts. But in your blog I find something that implies in blogging. Anyway, you’re unquestionably a great blogger and you have a skill to make your reader to keep reading your blog again and again. Keep up the magnificent work. Continue moving the people!

visit: custom essay writing service

 

The background is interesting man need to search more about the history

Beliefs to each one its own, but some of the best uk essay I ahave come across teach us that we all have been created and born as Human Beings first, regardlesss of which religion the doctor, mother and baby belongs to,

Amandaloren's picture

Freedom of religion is a rule that backings the opportunity of an individual or group, in public or private, to show religion or faith in teaching, practice, love, and worship. Buy Assignment Service it additionally incorporates the freedom to change one's religion or belief.

I just loved this cake and I inspired by this blog it has taken my attention. It was amazing to read this.  Need Assignment Help The concept of this blog and cake was amazing...

You mcm bags may knockoff handbags have oakley canada the nike outlet thought jimmy choo shoes that swarovski canada gaming is nba jerseys only mont blanc for air jordan retro children. oakley vault You jordan jerseys are nike outlet store quite prada sunglasses wrong! nike free Many chrome hearts store Nostalrius barbour outlet online are bucks jersey designed 49ers nfl jersey for ipad mini cases adults ray-ban sunglasses to nike canada enjoy, nike huaraches from chi flat iron role-playing military games the north face outlet to louboutin uk exercise tn pas cher games. ray ban outlet online There's trail blazers jersey a fred perry uk lot nike shoes to michael kors handbags learn, burberry so prada outlet keep michael kors reading.

 

Sit texans nfl jersey down basketball shoes and timberland boots play cheap oakley sunglasses some Nostalrius hilfiger online shop together nike free run 5.0 with ray ban black friday your vikings nfl jersey children. mcm bags You pacers jersey will bcbg max get michael kors to hollister know salvatore ferragamo your new balance shoes children oakley sunglasses outlet better ray ban sunglasses outlet and lions nfl jersey find hogan out oakley sunglasses outlet more burberry outlet store about air max things kings jersey they versace shoes outlet like. air max When burberry you salomon have michael kors handbags an christian louboutin interest cheap barbour jackets in timberwolves jersey common nike Air Max Plaza with a longchamp black friday child kobe bryant jerseys you giants nfl jersey will hugo boss clothes find ray ban outlet that puma sneakers conversations ralph lauren factory store flow north face more michael kors canada easily. atlanta hawks jersey You louboutin outlet can new balance spend replica rolex time with ravens nfl jersey them browns nfl jersey while hogan women shoes aiding burberry handbags outlet them in ray ban outlet their fitflop outlet skill ray ban development

 

If ray ban sunglasses outlet you tommy hilfiger do cowboys nfl jersey not seahawks nfl jersey play falcons nfl jersey a michael kors uk game air max any wizards jersey longer, kevin durant jersey you red bottoms can still skechers shoes outlet make michael kors money dsquared2 outlet off birkenstock shoes of woolrich mens jackets it. watches canada Trade jordans or sell coach outlet online these dwyane wade jersey games philipp plein clothing in cheap nhl jerseys second-hand barbour jackets stores. michael kors You coach factory outlet online can juicy couture sell dsquared2 jeans it converse for puma online cash, givenchy handbags or omega watches trade veneta it michael kors in huarache for michael kors a raptors jersey game louboutin outlet that michael kors handbags is new to soccer shoes you.

 

It tory burch shoes can birkenstock be ralph lauren hard marc jacobs to versace clothes pick rolex replica out longchamp handbags what burberry handbags outlet system handbags outlet you instyler want to supra footwear buy. coach store online You nike mercurial need adidas online to cheap mlb jerseys assess swarovski jewelry your hogan outlet needs coach outlet usa for cheap oakley gaming swarovski crystal first nike and ray bans then oakley black friday look softball bats at philadelphia 76ers jerseys the cheap nhl jerseys additional nike features swarovski offered converse shoes with ralph lauren polo the cavaliers jerseys console. fake rolex Do coach factory online your giuseppe shoes research skechers mens shoes by hermes using nike air yeezy the michael kors Internet. Go orlando magic jersey over ferragamo various celine bags reviews north face backpacks of skechers the asics gel consoles jimmy choo outlet that marc jacobs others red bottom shoes have kate spade outlet online posted. nike air force Do jerseys from china not hermes bags buy nike tracksuits a north face gaming baseball bats system timberland shoes without swarovski online knowing timberland outlet what lunette oakley to nba jersey expect.

 

Nostalrius ray ban outlet can hilfiger outlet be converse a cheap jerseys fabulous coach bags way oakley to nike roshe get polo ralph lauren exercise aktienkurse adidas these plein outlet days. michael kors purses Technology coach handbags that uses hollisterco motion indoor soccer shoes sensing has hermes birkin bag gone viral michael kors outlet through the swarovski jewelry gaming burberry outlet industry. cheap mlb jerseys That under armour curry lets air force you fossil uhren engage rams nfl jersey in broncos nfl jersey gaming kate spade outlet online while using ralph lauren polos your pandora schmuck own cheap michael kors muscles, beats by dr dre playing ralph lauren online sports louboutin and burberry sale practicing ralph lauren online shop yoga. grizzlies jersey You true religion can ray ban sonnenbrillen work lunette ray ban out adidas and adidas outlet get prada handbags in burberry handbags shape right true religion outlet in long champ front north face jackets of coach outlet sale the longchamp outlet TV.

 

Stay jazz jersey hydrated ray ban when boston celtics you oakley are air jordan shoes gaming barbour jackets for nike outlet a chi hair long salvatore ferragamo time. chiefs nfl jersey Although free run Nostalrius nike air max are azcardinals nfl jersey an new balance canada excellent bcbg max azria method panthers nfl jersey of relieving north face stress, cheap jerseys lots patriots nfl jersey of michael kors purses people iphone 5 cases can omega watches become air jordans addicted saints nfl jersey and designer handbags forget burberry handbags to cheap clothes drink. pandora jewelry When packers nfl jersey you adidas are playing armani shoes outlet Nostalrius, north face outlet remember chaussure timberland to ralph lauren outlet online drink air max 2015 a omega lot michael kors handbags of ralph lauren polos water raiders nfl jersey because calvin klein underwear dehydration coach outlet online can oakley sunglasses outlet make nike roche run you ill.

 

Although nike a air max one PS2 knicks jersey isn't nike air max the coach store best ralph lauren outlet gaming nike roshe system true religion jeans women out tommy hilfiger there ralph lauren now, dre beats they bottega veneta are very beats audio cheap vans and michael kors there coach store outlet are phoenix suns a lot dolphins nfl jersey of oakley sunglasses quality rockets jersey games out coach purses factory there pandora uk for asics it. nike Games ed hardy for oakley sunglasses cheap these less-expensive jordan consoles nike air max 2014 can roshe runs sell michael kors taschen for thomas sabo less hollisterco than titans nfl jersey half fidget spinner the ralph lauren cost coach factory of denver nuggets jersey games buccaneers nfl jersey for jets nfl jersey the pandora more thomas sabo expensive polo ralph lauren outlet online consoles. stone island outlet There christian louboutin shoes are polo ralph lauren outlet lots oakley sunglasses of coach handbags used valentino games ray ban wayfarer out eagles nfl jersey there, dallas mavericks jerseys too.

 

If ralph lauren outlet you nike.com let beats by dr dre your hilfiger outlet kids max shoes play cheap oakley sunglasses games burberry sale online, ray bans it coach outlet canada is prada shoes crucial occhiali oakley that ferragamo shoes you cheap jordans monitor burberry sale their cartier montres activity. oakley Limit their hollister interactions hollister kids if they michael kors play tory burch handbags online. kids hoodies Some predators mizuno running use bills nfl jersey Nostalrius to cheap glasses approach reebok children ray ban and replica rolex often northface pretend barbour jackets to burberry be roshe a discount shoes child. Always oakley sunglasses protect air max your fred perry outlet children tommy hilfiger and monitor nike mercurial their horloges online cheap ray ban activities hollister and new balance outlet the longchamp people prada they jaguars nfl jersey interact with cheap nike shoes online.

 

Watch jordans your pandora body nike shoes outlet when vans shoes you play ralph lauren outlet online Nostalrius. supra shoes If adidas canada you five finger shoes sit rolex watches down nike air huarache when cheap true religion playing michael kors bags games, cheap jerseys you eyeglasses stores may chargers nfl jersey want juicy couture outlet to use colts nfl jersey a mcm handbags stability san antonio spurs jersey ball the north face which nike can steelers nfl jersey help nike air huarache to oakley vault straighten michael kors outlet out golden state warriors jerseys your michael kors purses spine. ralph lauren uk Also, babyliss pro be sure ray ban and take giuseppe zanotti sneakers regular ralph lauren outlet online breaks vans and cheap true religion stretch longchamp every ferragamo shoes so michael kors outlet often. nike air max 2014 https://www.mmotank.com/Nostalrius/gold.html

 

More north face and adidas more converse sneakers adults nfl jerseys are redskins nfl jersey finding nike free run joy mbt mens shoes in longchamp Nostalrius burberry outlet online that fendi bags are new balance no clippers jersey longer aimed katespade towards michael kors bags just dansko outlet kids. polo ralph If pandora charms you cheap oakley sunglasses wish hollister co to occhiali ray ban get nike air max yourself coach handbags outlet acquainted nba jersey with adidas outlet Nostalrius charlotte hornets jerseys PVE polo ralph lauren and ecco outlet online be birkenstock taschen outlet professional roshe run with tommy hilfiger it, nike air max use new orleans pelicans the longchamp outlet above michael kors paragraphs. coach outlet online Use bengals nfl jersey the information air max 90 located ralph lauren above michael kors outlet to true religion jeans men help lacoste outlet online you handbags outlet become mcm handbags outlet a bears nfl jersey Elysium brooklyn nets jersey PVP mcm handbags pro.

levi's jeans